Since training is part of the FSGO "Seven Elements" model there are many individuals and companies willing to provide related services. There are also, increasingly, regulatory requirements for training in particular topics and definitions of what constitutes "effective " training.
What is "training"?
In California, for example, a state law and accompanying regulations require any company with more than 50 employees in the state to provide its supervisors two hours of sexual harassment training biannually. Besides setting the requirement (and the"carrot" of an affirmative defense to harassment claims for those comply) the regulations also spell out the required backgrounds for trainers, what formats will be considered "effective interactive training'" and specific learning objectives. Learn more
Similarly, the federal and state OSHA authorities have long ruled that their training requirements cannot be met by purely online modules. The participant must also have access to a "qualified trainer" to ask questions, give a "hands-on" demonstration of competence and receive a certificate of completion. Learn more
Other regulatory requirements may include (1) who must be trained; (2) how completion / mastery is documented; (3) frequency; (4) within x days / months of hire or association; (5) a minimum period of supervised field experience before the participant is "trained". The latest Corporate Integrity Agreement with Hill-Rom incorporates most of these. Specialized training of Board members about their role is also routinely required in CIAs.
A recently enacted Texas statute relating to electronic storage of "sensitive personal information" is a good illustration of some of the challenges posed by government training requirements. Effective September 1, 2012 each "covered entity" under the statute is required to provide training reflecting its "particular course of business" and the employee's "scope of employment" about protected health information, its use and access to it. That sounds like "one size fits all" training won't be sufficient. The statute doesn't specify format, length or method of delivery requirements, but it does mandate that the training must be completed within 60 days of hire and repeated every other year. And as part of the training the employee must sign a verification - electronically or physically - of "attendance" at the program. So does this last requirement mean the training must be in person? Or could "completion" = "attendance"?
Government provided training
Some agencies have gone so far as to create and deliver training in topics they consider relevant - e.g. the DHHS OIG provider compliance training in connection with its HEAT initiative - and / or publish it on the Web. The same OIG posted video training (and accompanying materials) - which although aimed as physicians could also be useful in training staff who work with them and or assist in their billing. Similarly, in 2011 California created a series of videos that are required viewing by those charged with reporting elder and dependent adult abuse.
Sometimes government training even comes with the incentive of continuing education credit, e.g. these HIPAA training modules from the Office for Civil Rights via Medscape.
Government Provided Training Resources on the Web:
The LA County Department of Health Services took a self-study approach to Compliance Awareness Training (2009 edition - pdf) then moved to an online module.
Maricopa County Health District trains its Board about Corporate Compliance (2013)
The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services has shared videos that it uses to train its surveyors, like the one on boundaries - To Do or Not to Do (2012)
Dartmouth Hitchcock teaches its employees about its Social Media policy (video)
Since training is part of the FSGO "Seven Elements" model there are many individuals and companies willing to provide related services. There are also, increasingly, regulatory requirements for training in particular topics and definitions of what constitutes "effective " training.
What is "training"?
In California, for example, a state law and accompanying regulations require any company with more than 50 employees in the state to provide its supervisors two hours of sexual harassment training biannually. Besides setting the requirement (and the"carrot" of an affirmative defense to harassment claims for those comply) the regulations also spell out the required backgrounds for trainers, what formats will be considered "effective interactive training'" and specific learning objectives. Learn more
Similarly, the federal and state OSHA authorities have long ruled that their training requirements cannot be met by purely online modules. The participant must also have access to a "qualified trainer" to ask questions, give a "hands-on" demonstration of competence and receive a certificate of completion. Learn more
Other regulatory requirements may include (1) who must be trained; (2) how completion / mastery is documented; (3) frequency; (4) within x days / months of hire or association; (5) a minimum period of supervised field experience before the participant is "trained". The latest Corporate Integrity Agreement with Hill-Rom incorporates most of these. Specialized training of Board members about their role is also routinely required in CIAs.
A recently enacted Texas statute relating to electronic storage of "sensitive personal information" is a good illustration of some of the challenges posed by government training requirements. Effective September 1, 2012 each "covered entity" under the statute is required to provide training reflecting its "particular course of business" and the employee's "scope of employment" about protected health information, its use and access to it. That sounds like "one size fits all" training won't be sufficient. The statute doesn't specify format, length or method of delivery requirements, but it does mandate that the training must be completed within 60 days of hire and repeated every other year. And as part of the training the employee must sign a verification - electronically or physically - of "attendance" at the program. So does this last requirement mean the training must be in person? Or could "completion" = "attendance"?
Government provided training
Some agencies have gone so far as to create and deliver training in topics they consider relevant - e.g. the DHHS OIG provider compliance training in connection with its HEAT initiative - and / or publish it on the Web. The same OIG posted video training (and accompanying materials) - which although aimed as physicians could also be useful in training staff who work with them and or assist in their billing. Similarly, in 2011 California created a series of videos that are required viewing by those charged with reporting elder and dependent adult abuse.
The New York Medicaid Inspector General's office has posted audio and slides from its webinars on various compliance topics. And CMS has long made available extensive training resources in various formats about Medicare, e.g. Guidelines for Physicians at Teaching Hospitals, Residents and Interns. In September 2012 CMS began distributing "Hand in Hand: A Training Series for Nursing Homes" which consists of six one hour videos and an instruction guide aimed at better treatment of those with dementia and the prevention of abuse.
Sometimes government training even comes with the incentive of continuing education credit, e.g. these HIPAA training modules from the Office for Civil Rights via Medscape.
Government Provided Training Resources on the Web:
Federal
The Federal Reserve Board has training for Bank Directors
The Office for Human Research Protections has made available video training for Institutional Review Boards.
The IRS has training for 501 (c)(3) organizations at "Stay Exempt.org"
The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) offers training for bank managers, including compliance training
Office of Government Ethics offers various resources, including "The Ethical Choice: Ethics for Special Government Employees" like contractors and consultants (2011)(video)
The federal **Interagency Ethics Council** blog has regular features on "Training Aids" and Training Tips"
The Dept of Justice, Office of Special Counsel has Webinars on Immigration Related Unfair Employment Practices OSC also offers a subscription service regarding technical assistance letters it issues on this topic.
Medicare Learning Network (CMS)
Medicare Guided Pathways for Providers and Suppliers
DHHS OIG Compliance Training Video Series
US Department of Transportation has resources on drug and alcohol testing including a mock collection training video
U.S. Department of Labor has 'Compliance Clips
State
Required ethics training for lobbyists and their employers in Alaska
EEO and Diversity training from the DC Office of Human Rights
A range of environmental compliance courses from California's Air Resources Board
What others have done about training:
Government Required Training
Mandatory training under a Corporate Integrity Agreement (White Memorial Medical Center 2013)(video)
Compliance
Baptist Health's Corporate Compliance for Interns
Canon's Compliance awareness training starts with Compliance Week
The Catholic University of America delivers its compliance awareness training online
Annual Refresher Compliance Training, Community, Work and Independence, Inc. (2012) (3 videos)
Community Health Group's 2014 Compliance Training Module
Annual Board training at "Happy Health Plan of America"
The Harris County Hospital District's General Compliance Training (2011)
IBC has general compliance and HIPAA training for its vendors.
General Corporate Compliance Training Jackson Health System 2015
Kaiser Permanente has Annual Compliance Training (2013)
The LA County Department of Health Services took a self-study approach to Compliance Awareness Training (2009 edition - pdf) then moved to an online module.
Maricopa County Health District trains its Board about Corporate Compliance (2013)
Compliance training for the Medigold Provider Network (scroll down)
Mid South Rehab Services Annual Compliance Training "It's A Black and White Affair" (4 videos 2012)
New Mexico State University's Compliance Training portal
Training plan for New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation (Marrero, 2012)
Another hospital organization training plan (2012)
Oxford Healthcare's 2014 Compliance training
Plexus presents "Compliance Dos and Don'ts" (2014)(video)
Ryder Rents Trucks - and Compliance Training
Training in "The Statoil Book" and the "management system" it is part of (speakers useful)
New hire Integrity and Compliance Program Orientation at Trinity Health (2014)
The University of California's Education and Training options
Including an annual Compliance and Audit Symposium for those in the system.
In 2015, the University of Connecticut is doing both online and inperson Compliance Training
The University of Washington's Medical School had an annual Compliance and Ethics Quiz for employees (2012)
Daniel J. Weissburg, JD CHC, of the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health uses video to share his training sessions
Annual Training for Executives and the Compliance and Business Integrity Committee (Veteran's Affairs Palo Alto 2013) (video)
Wildwood Programs used video + technology to deliver and test its 2012 Compliance Training
Ethics
The City of Austin has its 2015 Citywide Ethics Training on its website.
Central Texas College District Ethics and Code of Conduct Training (2010) (video)
Cisco's Ethics Training in China (2011) (video)
Chicago Board of Ethics Training (2010) (video)
Dental Students teach about their Code of Ethics in "The Unprofessional" (2011)(video)
Rollout of Ethics Training in a Multinational Corporation - Electrolux (2011)
Integrity In The Workplace (Federal Law Enforcement Training Center, Dept of Treasury 1990)
Harris County Texas Ethics Training (2010) (video with sign language captioning)
City of Huntington Beach Ethics Training (2010) (video)
The Train Problem - IGA / Coca Cola Business Ethics Course (2012)(video)
Indyne's Annual "Attorney Client Protected" Procurement Integrity and Ethics Training (2011) (video)
Lockheed Martin's Integrity Minute series
Lockheed's "Voicing Our Values" Ethics Training (2014)
Ethics: Making the Right Choice (Maricopa County 2008) (video)
Ethics Orientation for New Employees at Northern Illinois University (2015)
Resolving an Unethical Situation (SDSU 2011)(video and follow-up survey)
Annual Ethics Training for Employees (SIU 2013) and the 2015 version at Edwardsville
City of Southlake, Texas Ethics Training (2011)
The USDA ethics training for new employees combines humor and substance
Ethics Awareness Training at Yavapai College (2011)
Yokogawa Electric Corporation's Compliance "Enlightenment Activities"
Specific Topics
Compliance Officer Jeff Petro uses humor to teach employees about the organization's policies (video)(2013)
The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services has shared videos that it uses to train its surveyors, like the one on boundaries - To Do or Not to Do (2012)
Dartmouth Hitchcock teaches its employees about its Social Media policy (video)
HCA's Code of Conduct training described
Hospital Code of Conduct Training (video)
This Intel supplier uses music, video and a little humor to teach its Harassment and open door policies. (2011)(video)
Northrup Grumman publishes "test yourself" brochures on various compliance topics - like this one on the Export Controls
Financial Compliance training delivered via the web using Adobe Captivate (U. of Missouri)
The University of Pennsylvania has a downloadable Pocket Compliance Guide for sponsored projects
The University of Texas' Systemwide Compliance Academy Webinairs cover a wide range of topics
Executive Ethical Compliance Training - Worksite immigration Symposium - at Stanford (2012)
Billing Staff Departmental Training from the Yale Medical Group (speakers required)
A school district's OSHA training video series
Business Ethics case, Would You Blow the Whistle on Your Boss? (Drinan, Simmons College, 2008)(video)
The Bell Ringer from the Salvation Army (1990) (a classic in less than 8 minutes)
Theories about training
Privacy and Security Training : Why Train? What is Effective? (Solove 2013)
Compliance Training (Macro Man 2013)
Building Compliance Training (Yancey & Bozarth 2013)(video)
Business Ethics Training (Moran 2012)
Curbing Wasteful Compliance Training (Paskoff 2012)
Telling Isn't Training (Harden 2011)
Teaching Business Ethics Objectives (DesJardins 2011) (video)
Using the Ethics Board Game to Teach Business Ethics (Ferrall 2011)
How to Make Corporate Training Rock (Heath 2010)
Teaching that Sticks (Heath 2010)
"Improving Compliance Education" - various compliance officers being interviewed about Compliance Education (2010) (video)
Employees Learn Best From Video Games (U. of Denver, 2010)
How a 3-year project led us to Scenario-based case design (Dickinson 2010)
Tips on using Video in Training (Impact Video 2008)
The Ethics Challenge : Using Game Theory - U of MN Duluth
Description of Lockheed Martin's Ethics Challenge board game
Training Tip # 8 - The Humor Paradox
Shared by Toolbox members:
< Click "edit" above and start typing here>